Responding to Journals

One of the goals of journaling in this class is to introduce you to and give you practice in the expectations of academic discourse. Responding to classmates' journals as described below will not only do that, but it will help you develop ideas for essays later in the class. In journaling, responses tend to fall into one of the three types. What we are shooting for when we talk about academic discourse, is the third type of response. Those are the responses that will earn you full credit. With each assignment you are expected to respond to at least three entries posted by your classmates; at least one of your responses should be a response to one of the responses to your journal.

  1. Affective Responses are expressions of personal views and/or responses. These sorts of responses tell the reader what the writer thinks about the topic, nothing more.
  2. That's totally cool. I completely agree.

  3. Cohesive Responses will contain the elements of an affective response while also trying to acknowledge the presence or work of others but without seeking any feedback or contribution from the original writer or other readers.
  4. That's totally cool what you wrote about Hester and Dimmesdale. I like how you did that.

  5. Interactive Responses contain elements of both affective and cohesive responses while actively and explicitly seeking feedback and responses from other writers while incorporating thoughts, passages and ideas from the writer they are responding to at the very least, and other responses as well. To take advantage of the medium (the blog) they will also provide links to those comments or ideas that add to the discussion, whether part of the class blog or material found elsewhere on the internet.
  6. I like what you had to say about how Hester really isn't the victim she gets made out to be. I think I agree because even though everyone shuns her, unless they want something from her, she is in control of her destiny, if only because she has determined it's up to God when the letter comes off, not everyone else, Dimmesdale in particular. Did you, or anyone, notice other examples where she showed herself to be a strong woman, not just a victim? Or maybe examples that fit with Pearl? I'm trying to think of some but can't right off the top of my head.

Blogging should be agonistic, deliberative and collaborative. That means we should argue with each other, politely. This is part of what makes blogging a pedagogically sound activity for the development of academic discourse. This happens when we read and respond to one another's posts, when we respond to one another's responses and acknowledge and account for others' perspectives in our own posts. Interactive responses are what is being sought and the only sort of response that will be awarded full credit when it comes time to tally grades.


Where are we are suppose to see the Journal Topic for the week?

Journal Topic

You can find the week's Journal by going to 'Home' and then you can find it between the book club groups and reaction charts

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.